Forum Groups
  All forums
    Help & Feedback
      Questions
      Work in progress
      Finished Art
      Non-Max related
    Community
      Offtopic
      News
    Hardware
    Photography



Maxunderground news unavailable

 
First page  Go to the previous page   [01]  [02]  Go to the next page  Last page
 
banding
show user profile  STRAT

Hi chaps, take a close look at the above render sample.

It rendered beautifully, but after changing the shadow/highlight in photoshop i get this terrible banding all over the image.

I render out in 16 bit TIFF format and amend in 64BIT photoshop.

why is this happening, surely my 16BIT renders should stop all this completely?





SJLEWORTHY.COM











read 334 times
1/7/2016 5:55:37 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 5:55:37 PM)
show user profile  chillywilson
Is photoshop reading them as 8bit. go to image mode and see if it is on 8 or 16

[edit] also make sure your using 16bit adjustments.
read 323 times
1/7/2016 6:42:37 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 6:43:42 PM)
show user profile  STRAT
mode is 16 bit.

how do i know if im making 16bit adjustments as opposed to 8bit then?





SJLEWORTHY.COM











read 315 times
1/7/2016 6:51:46 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 6:51:46 PM)
show user profile  chillywilson
sorry it's only AE that has 8bit only adjustments.
Can you dropbox a still I can take a look.

read 313 times
1/7/2016 6:57:03 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 6:57:03 PM)
show user profile  STRAT
http://www.sjleworthy.com/temp/test.tif

for instance, try shadow/highlight - shadows = 0 highlights = 100






SJLEWORTHY.COM











read 306 times
1/7/2016 7:06:34 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:08:23 PM)
show user profile  Error404
it looks like you're doing some sort of shadow enhancement, that operation may be causing the banding.

Do you see the banding before you output the JPG?

(edit) I don't see any banding on the TIF you uploaded. If you are workig in 16 bit in photoshop, you shouldn't see banding for most things.

www.DanielBuck.net - www.DNSFail.com

read 304 times
1/7/2016 7:08:04 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:09:59 PM)
show user profile  STRAT
yes

all rendering and amending is done in 16bit then saved down to jpg. this banding is from the shadow/highlights option in 16bit before jpg.

i didnt think 16bit should do this.





SJLEWORTHY.COM











read 302 times
1/7/2016 7:08:53 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:09:50 PM)
show user profile  Error404
if you crank on an image hard enough, it will band, but for most things you shouldn't see it. DO you see the banding before exporting? Try collapsing the layers to one layer before you save as JPG.

www.DanielBuck.net - www.DNSFail.com

read 298 times
1/7/2016 7:10:54 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:10:54 PM)
show user profile  STRAT
yes. the effect is most visible whatever way i try it in 16bit before jpg. try it yourself in my file i posted.

i can see sooner or later even 16bit will band, but i wasnt expecting this to be honest.
is there a photoshop fix/workaround?





SJLEWORTHY.COM











read 295 times
1/7/2016 7:12:36 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:12:36 PM)
show user profile  Error404
hm... yea I see what you mean. It looks like it's the shadow/highlight tool that's causing it. If I crank the image around with curves (instead of shadow/highlight), I don't see any banding.


Try opening the TIF in ACR, and do the shadow/highlight adjustments in there? That might work out better. Give me a sec, let me try that.

www.DanielBuck.net - www.DNSFail.com

read 293 times
1/7/2016 7:13:26 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:14:06 PM)
show user profile  STRAT
ACR ?





SJLEWORTHY.COM











read 290 times
1/7/2016 7:14:34 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:14:34 PM)
show user profile  Error404
camera raw.

filter > open with camera raw





ACR doesn't seem to cause banding when using the shadow/highlight sliders, but you don't have as extreme of an adjustment as the filter in photoshop does. I have a feeling it's the shadow/highlight tool. It's possible that the code for the S/H tool is internally doing some operation in 8 bit, or something else funky.


I'm not sure what a work around would be.

www.DanielBuck.net - www.DNSFail.com

read 288 times
1/7/2016 7:16:21 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:19:28 PM)
show user profile  STRAT
when i render in 8 bit and jpg, the shadow/highlight tool is a nightmare, even on modest cranks, but i was disappointed to see it in 16 bit more and more too. a shame, as the s/h tool is almost a must for me

didn't think there were any bugs left to find in Photoshop ;)





SJLEWORTHY.COM











read 277 times
1/7/2016 7:21:56 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 7:23:10 PM)
show user profile  chillywilson
Yeah I'm not getting banding until I crank it way up the shad and highs.

You should stay off of image/ adjustments and use adjustment layers like curves and levels, I can crank everything way up and not get the banding then.

edit: maybe that was the 8bit side I was thinking.
read 268 times
1/7/2016 8:25:57 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 8:27:06 PM)
show user profile  LionDebt
Were the walls damp when the plaster was applied? Also, your sea sponge looks radioactive, was it from Fukushima?
read 254 times
1/7/2016 10:20:27 PM (last edit: 1/7/2016 10:20:27 PM)
 
First page  Go to the previous page   [01]  [02]  Go to the next page  Last page
 
#Maxforums IRC
Open chat window


Support Maxforums.org